ISSUE 22, AUGUST, 1993

A critic grabs us, and says without a smile

"Leave the 'Unplugged' sessions to Eric Clapton or Rod Stewart. On his new album `Kamakiriad,' Fagen is plugged in, revved up and sounding like he was never away."
Gary Mullinax, Wilmington News Journal

"Though slightly more aggressive in the rhythm section, and somewhat fuller in the horn arrangements, 'Kamakiriad' is instantly recognizable as the late-period Steely Dan sound, a comparison made all the more pertinent by the presence of Fagen's old Dan cohort Walter Becker as producer, bassist and guitarist. Becker's quite a virtuoso: on guitar, he has a relaxed, swingy jazz style, while his bass lines bring to mind the circuitous peregrinations of the Motown legend James Jamerson. This track is one of the standouts -- though, as with 'The Nightfly,' there are no duds -- with Fagen's crafty lyric hints couched in the most incongruous of lounge-jazz idioms. Who else could sing a couplet like 'We hit the street with visors down/With our thermasuits sealed up tight' and make it seem like the most natural, wholesome, new-age thing on earth? Grown-up album of the year, so far."
Andy Gill, The Independent (U.K)

"From the streamlined funk of 'Tomorrow's Girls' to the bouncy saunter of 'Countermoon,' the songs find a groove and gather momentum as breezy vocals and serpentine horn charts glide over a swinging rhythm section. 'Trans-Island Skyway' builds from a muttering bass line and ice-cool finger snaps to an exhilarating joyride that derives part of its thrill from the danger lurking around the next bend. When Fagen sings, 'Strap in tight, 'cause it's a long sweet ride,' it's like speeding in a convertible with the top down."
Guy Garcia, Time

"Disco flashes back for 'Florida Room,' using Philadelphia International hi-hat cymbals and a plucky motor-booty shake made famous by K.C. and the Sunshine Band at Miami's T.K. Records. It's a Saturday Night Feverish arrangement, heavy on the '70s production features, and enjoyable in a retro way."
Michael Snyder, The San Francisco Chronicle

"Where `The Nightfly' looked back on a mythical American past, 'Kamakiriad' places itself on the cusp on the millennium. This is the Fagen-Becker sensibility filtered through Philip K. Dick, a world of cyborg cuties ('Tomorrow's Girls'), virtual reality ('Springtime'), and a car called a Kamakiri that has a vegetable garden in the back ('Trans-Island Skyway'). 'The Nightfly' was a monstrously hard act to follow, but incredibly Fagen has pulled it off. I don't know when he is planning to release his third solo album, but when he does I will be first in line, pension book in hand."
Tony Parsons, The Daily Telegraph (U.K)

"The album's wacky lyrics, loopy sci-fi motif, and spooky adenoidal singing all count it as one of the can't-miss candidates for '90s legend-status. The core musical configuration of Fagen's vocals and keyboards, Becker's bass and Georg Wadenius' guitar is cushioned by horn arrangements that sparkle and shine like the reefs of Kizmar. If you don't yet comprehend what that means, you'll just have to climb into the Kamakiri, start the engine, and learn as you go. Right when you get to the Smokehouse in the sand!"
Billboard Magazine

"Donald Fagen and Walter Becker are back together for Fagen's new record, and the results are stunning. This is as good as it gets for rock/jazz/pop fusion. It takes place in the future and begins with 'Trans-Island Skyway,' a funky number that tells the story of a guy about to take a journey in his new dream car, a custom-tooled Kamakiri. The tale gets weirder as it goes along, but the music is exhilarating throughout. The story line is not easy to follow, but this record remains an invigorating listening experience. Fagen and Becker haven't done much the past few years, but this is a comeback record that proves they haven't lost a thing. 'Kamakiriad' is creative, refreshing and a total joy."
Anthony Violanti, The Buffalo News

"In truth though, it's just not the vocals that are low key. The entire album is the light funk equivalent of musical foreplay, always simmering but rarely taking it over the top."
Kevin B. O'Hare, Syndicated music critic (and friend of John Kane's)

"On 'The Nightfly' Mr. Fagen came across both cool and approachable, pairing glistening melodies with warm, nostalgic yearnings for the lost innocence of the Kennedy era that come from his heart rather than just his head. Here, he is retracing his steps, settling for a Steely Dan throwback that -- while certainly colorful -- is more paint-by-numbers than masterpiece."
David Okamoto, The Dallas Morning News

"No, they rarely make albums like this anymore -- which is exactly what seems amiss. A good chunk of what is called pop these days -- from sloppy grunge to jumping rap -- sounds as if it were swiftly pieced together in someone's basement. By contrast, 'Kamakiriad' recalls a time when musicians and producers would spend months or years in the studio in search of the perfect pop record -- and when melody, not crackling, jubilant noise came first. Just to prove how old-world it is, 'Kamakiriad' is one of those antiquities known as a concept album. The low-energy melodies amble along in a pleasant but noodling way, with an exception being the jaunty 'Hey Nineteen'-like swing of 'Tomorrow's Girls.' That's where Fagen's perfectionism gets in the way. You have to admire him for taking his work so seriously, but those diligent arrangements only tend to zap whatever spontaneity existed to begin with. And spontaneity -- or at least implied spontaneity -- is the trademark sound of '90s pop. To anyone other than the baby boomer Dan fans who have been eagerly awaiting this album, 'Kamakiriad' will probably be perceived as a quaint theme park all its own: a pop world that has itself gone the way of the carnival calliope."
David Browne, Entertainment Weekly

"But 'Kamakiriad' isn't just an 'Aja' minor. For the first time, Fagen instills his music with full emotional openness, and without the old ironic knots to be negotiated. The prevailing tones of ache and longing have more dimension and resonance. It can be funny and touching, but it adds up to a pretty hard-bitten confrontation with self, making the climactic transformation-redemption symbolized by the jazz way of life, in the best Steely Dan tradition -- all the richer."
Richard Cromelin, Los Angeles Times

"... 'Kamakiriad' may depict a Grave New World, but one that's described so artistically (Fagen's singing is more expressive than ever) and juxtaposed with such graceful music and superb musicianship that it leaves you somehow feeling wonderful afterward. This is one of the year's outstanding albums"
Terry Atkinson, Prodigy Interactive Computer Service

"Fagen's new album 'Kamakiriad' is very much in the spirit of its predecessors but is even drier in tone and more enigmatic. A futuristic song cycle, suggests the fantasy of an overgrown kid who dreams of touring the galaxy in the coolest automobile ever built. Over the next few songs he stops at various locations in a future world that suggests a sleek, ultratechnologized caricature of the one we live in. 'Tomorrow's Girls' creates a superwoman-from-outer-space scenario that is part 'War Of The Worlds' (via Orson Welles), part 'Invasion Of The Body Snatchers', part 'Barbarella."'
Stephen Holden, Rolling Stone

"Perhaps nostalgia is just bare sentimentality, but that's right at the root of Fagen and Becker's own delight in Charlie Parker's band, madness 'bout Brubeck, and ability to get silly to 'Trane on the Trans-Island Skyway. The Odysseus of this tragicomikiriad understands the need to look back to see forward. Fagen is an illusionist, a cineastic composer with all the adorable idiosyncrasies and flourishes of Ellington or Woody Allen, and he possesses both those artists' gift for making such qualities inseparable. Maybe one day they'll all have lunch and talk about the good times."
Matt Resnicoff, Musician Magazine

"Fagen understands deep, spacious sound and the power of pervasive bass better than any other white soul man. The slowly fluttering textures of horns and keyboards alone recommend 'Kamakiriad' to confirmed Steely Dan fans. The uninitiated should go back to 'Pretzel Logic' or 'Countdown to Ecstasy' and work up to 'Kamakiriad' -- probably around the turn of the century."
Milos Miles, CD Review

"At its languid, lucid best, the album recalls the sacred first side of 'Aja'; compliments come no higher."
Richard William, The Independent (U.K.)

There must have been something in the Molson Ale up in The Great White North in May because none of the Canadian critics seemed to care much for the album. We can't figure it out but. maybe some of you can, eh?

"It starts off well enough, with the classic jazz-pop SD sound percolating through 'Trans-Island Skyway' and 'Countermoon,' but the eight tracks have a plodding sameness about them that ultimately slam 'Kamakiriad' into a brick wall."
Peter Howell, Toronto Star

"Could this really be the team that made 'Rikki Don't Lose That Number,' 'Reeling In The Years,' and 'Deacon Blues?'
John Mackie, The Vancouver Sun

"Unfortunately, the very need for brief synopsis of the plot in the liner notes says it all. When Steely Dan wrote great songs they were great. When they didn't, they were paint. As in watching it dry.
The Montreal Gazette

"Cool. Casual. Occasionally clever. And by day's end a lot like stroking a pair of nylons on the car seat beside you ... only no one's in them."
J.M., Calgary Herald

Metal Leg contents | The Steely Dan Internet Resource

Last modified on 2/2/2003